UP High Court RO / ARO 07 Jan 2022 Shift 2

Change the given sentence from direct speech to indirect speech :\nMy teacher often says to me, “If you don’t work hard, you will fail”.

Verified Answer
A. My teacher often says to me that if you don’t work hard you will fail.
B. My teacher often says to me that if I don’t work hard you will fail.
C. My teacher often says to me that if I don’t work hard I shall fail.
D. My teacher often says to me that if you don’t work hard I will fail.

Explanation:

This question tests your ability to convert a sentence from direct speech to indirect speech. The key rules to apply here are: 1. **Reporting Verb Tense:** The reporting verb 'says' is in the present tense. When the reporting verb is in the present or future tense, the tense of the verb in the reported speech does not change. 2. **Pronoun Changes:** Pronouns in the reported speech change according to the subject and object of the reporting verb. Here, 'you' in the direct speech refers to 'me' (the listener), so it should change to 'I' in indirect speech. 3. **Conjunction:** Use 'that' to introduce the reported statement. \nLet's analyze the original sentence: 'My teacher often says to me, “If you don’t work hard, you will fail”.' \nApplying the rules, the correct indirect speech should be: 'My teacher often says to me that if I don’t work hard, I will fail.' \nNow let's evaluate the options: \nOption A: 'My teacher often says to me that if you don’t work hard you will fail.' - This option incorrectly retains 'you' instead of changing it to 'I'. \nOption B: 'My teacher often says to me that if I don’t work hard you will fail.' - This option correctly changes the first 'you' to 'I' but incorrectly retains the second 'you'. \nOption C: 'My teacher often says to me that if I don’t work hard I shall fail.' - This option correctly changes both 'you' pronouns to 'I'. The use of 'shall' with 'I' for future tense, while less common than 'will' in modern English, is grammatically acceptable and traditionally correct, especially for expressing determination or a simple future. Given the other options have clear pronoun errors, this is the most grammatically sound choice. \nOption D: 'My teacher often says to me that if you don’t work hard I will fail.' - This option incorrectly retains the first 'you' and incorrectly changes the second 'you' to 'I', which reverses the intended meaning of who will fail. \nTherefore, Option C is the most accurate conversion, correctly handling the pronoun changes, even with the use of 'shall'.