UPPSC Mains 2020 Paper 2

What are the functions of Finance Commission? Examine its emerging role in Fiscal Federalism.

Verified Answer

The Finance Commission (FC) is a quasi-judicial body constituted by the President of India every five years under Article 280 of the Constitution. It plays a pivotal role in India's fiscal federalism, acting as a crucial bridge between the Union and State governments regarding financial resource allocation. Its primary objective is to address vertical and horizontal imbalances in public finances and ensure an equitable distribution of resources.

Core Functions of the Finance Commission (Traditional Role):

  1. Distribution of Net Proceeds of Taxes: The most significant function is to recommend the distribution of the net proceeds of taxes between the Union and the States (vertical devolution) and the allocation of these shares among the States themselves (horizontal devolution). This involves determining the divisible pool of central taxes and the criteria for distributing it.

  2. Principles Governing Grants-in-Aid: It lays down the principles that should govern the grants-in-aid of the revenues of the States out of the Consolidated Fund of India. These grants are often specific-purpose grants or gap-filling grants to assist states in meeting their expenditure needs or for specific developmental objectives.

  3. Measures to Augment State Funds for Local Bodies: The FC makes recommendations on measures needed to augment the Consolidated Fund of a State to supplement the resources of Panchayats and Municipalities in the State, based on the recommendations made by the State Finance Commissions.

  4. Any Other Matter: The President may refer any other matter to the Commission in the interests of sound finance.

Emerging Role in Fiscal Federalism:

The role of the Finance Commission has evolved significantly over the years, adapting to changes in India's economic and political landscape, particularly in the context of fiscal federalism:

  1. Post-GST Era: With the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), many indirect taxes previously shared between the Union and States are now subsumed. The FC's role in tax devolution has adapted to recommend the share of the divisible pool of GST and other central taxes, ensuring states receive their due share from the new tax regime.

  2. Performance-Based Grants and Conditionalities: Recent Finance Commissions have moved beyond mere resource distribution to incorporate performance-based grants. These grants are often linked to specific reforms undertaken by states in areas like fiscal consolidation, power sector reforms, ease of doing business, or environmental protection. This incentivizes states to adopt sound financial management and policy reforms, influencing state-level governance.

  3. Addressing Regional Disparities: The FC increasingly uses sophisticated criteria for horizontal devolution, considering factors like demographic performance, forest cover, income distance, area, and tax effort. This aims to address persistent regional disparities and promote balanced development across states, moving towards more equitable outcomes.

  4. Impact of NITI Aayog: With the abolition of the Planning Commission and the establishment of NITI Aayog, the distinction between 'plan' and 'non-plan' expenditure has blurred. While NITI Aayog focuses on strategic planning and policy formulation, the FC remains the constitutional body for statutory transfers, ensuring a clear division of responsibilities in fiscal transfers.

  5. Debt Management and Fiscal Responsibility: Finance Commissions now provide recommendations on state debt and fiscal responsibility frameworks, encouraging both the Union and States to maintain fiscal discipline and sustainability.

  6. Disaster Relief Funding: The FC also makes recommendations for financing disaster management funds, acknowledging the increasing frequency and intensity of natural calamities and their fiscal implications for states.

  7. Strengthening Local Bodies: The emphasis on augmenting resources for Panchayats and Municipalities has grown, recognizing their crucial role in grassroots governance and service delivery. The FC's recommendations aim to empower local self-governments financially.

In conclusion, the Finance Commission has transcended its traditional role as merely a resource distributor. It has evolved into a key institution that actively shapes India's fiscal federalism by promoting fiscal discipline, incentivizing reforms, addressing regional imbalances, and strengthening sub-national governments. Its recommendations are vital for fostering cooperative federalism, ensuring financial stability, and achieving inclusive growth across the diverse states of the Indian Union.