Anthropology optional 2021 Paper II

Concept of tribe and Indian census

Verified Answer

The concept of 'tribe' in India is complex, evolving from traditional anthropological definitions to a specific constitutional category. The Indian Census plays a crucial role in enumerating and providing data on these communities, which is vital for policy formulation.

Concept of Tribe: Traditionally, anthropologists characterized tribes as relatively isolated, self-contained social groups with distinct cultural traits, a common language/dialect, strong kinship ties, a segmentary social organization (often egalitarian), and an economy based on subsistence activities like hunting, gathering, or shifting cultivation. They were often seen as 'primitive' or 'pre-literate' societies.

However, this traditional view has been critiqued for being static and not reflecting the dynamic realities of tribal communities, many of whom have been in contact with non-tribal societies for centuries and exhibit varying degrees of socio-economic differentiation. In India, the term 'Adivasi' (original inhabitants) is often preferred by tribal communities themselves, emphasizing their indigenous status.

Constitutionally, in India, 'tribes' are recognized as 'Scheduled Tribes' (STs) under Article 342. While the Constitution does not define 'tribe,' the criteria historically used for their identification include:

  • Indications of primitive traits.
  • Distinctive culture.
  • Geographical isolation.
  • Shyness of contact with the community at large.
  • Backwardness (economic and educational).

Indian Census and Tribes: The Indian Census is instrumental in providing the statistical backbone for understanding the Scheduled Tribe population. Its role is multifaceted:

  1. Enumeration and Demographics: The Census systematically enumerates the ST population across the country, providing crucial data on their numbers, distribution, sex ratio, age structure, and growth rates. This data is essential for understanding their demographic profile.
  2. Socio-Economic Indicators: It collects vital socio-economic data, including literacy rates, educational attainment levels, occupational structure, workforce participation, housing conditions, and access to basic amenities. This helps in assessing their development status and identifying areas of deprivation.
  3. Cultural and Linguistic Data: The Census also gathers information on the languages spoken and religious affiliations of STs, contributing to the understanding of their cultural diversity.
  4. Policy Formulation and Implementation: The comprehensive data collected by the Census is indispensable for the government to formulate, implement, and monitor welfare policies, development programs, and affirmative action (reservations in education, employment, and political representation) specifically targeted at the upliftment and integration of STs.
  5. Monitoring Progress and Impact Assessment: By providing data at regular intervals (every ten years), the Census allows for monitoring the progress of STs over time and evaluating the effectiveness of various interventions and schemes aimed at their development.

Challenges in Census Enumeration:

  • Identification Issues: Discrepancies can arise between self-identification and the official list of STs, which is notified by the President.
  • Accessibility: Reaching remote and inaccessible tribal areas for accurate enumeration can be challenging.
  • Assimilation: Some tribal groups have undergone significant acculturation, making their identification based on traditional criteria complex.

In conclusion, the concept of tribe in India has evolved into a constitutional category of Scheduled Tribes. The Indian Census serves as a critical tool for collecting comprehensive data on these communities, which is fundamental for evidence-based policy-making, ensuring their welfare, and promoting their equitable development and inclusion in the national mainstream.