Geography Optional 2019 Paper II

Correlate the price of land, vertical growth of cities and the growth of slums in large cities of India.

Verified Answer

In large cities of India, the price of land, vertical growth, and the proliferation of slums are intricately linked phenomena, forming a complex urban dynamic driven by rapid urbanization, economic disparities, and inadequate planning.

1. High Price of Land:

  • Drivers: Large Indian cities experience immense pressure on land due to continuous rural-to-urban migration, limited available land within city limits, speculative investments, and high demand for residential, commercial, and industrial spaces. This scarcity, coupled with high demand, inflates land prices significantly.
  • Impact: Exorbitant land prices make formal housing unaffordable for a vast segment of the urban population, particularly low and middle-income groups. Developers also face high acquisition costs, which are then passed on to buyers.

2. Vertical Growth of Cities:

  • Response to Land Prices: To maximize returns on expensive land and accommodate the growing population within limited urban footprints, cities are increasingly adopting vertical growth. This involves constructing high-rise residential apartments, commercial complexes, and mixed-use buildings.
  • Economic Viability: For developers, building upwards allows for a higher Floor Space Index (FSI) or Floor Area Ratio (FAR), enabling them to construct more saleable area on a smaller, costly plot of land, thereby making projects economically viable.
  • Urban Planning: City master plans and zoning regulations often encourage vertical development in designated areas to manage population density and optimize infrastructure usage. This is seen as a way to create compact, efficient cities.
  • Infrastructure Strain: While vertical growth can save horizontal space, it puts immense strain on existing urban infrastructure like water supply, sewerage, electricity, and transportation, often leading to congestion and resource scarcity if not planned adequately.

3. Growth of Slums:

  • Unaffordable Housing: The most direct correlation between high land prices, vertical growth, and slums is the affordability crisis. As formal housing (including high-rise apartments) becomes prohibitively expensive, low-income migrants and existing urban poor are priced out of the formal housing market.
  • Migration and Livelihoods: People continue to migrate to cities in search of economic opportunities. Unable to afford formal housing, they are forced to seek shelter in informal settlements or slums, often on marginal lands (riverbanks, railway lines, public land, or ecologically sensitive areas) or in dilapidated structures.
  • Proximity to Work: Slums often emerge close to economic centers where jobs are available, even if the land is unsuitable or illegal for habitation. This proximity is crucial for daily wage earners who cannot afford long commutes.
  • Displacement and Relocation: Vertical growth projects, especially those involving urban renewal or infrastructure development, often lead to the displacement of existing slum dwellers. If proper rehabilitation and resettlement policies are not in place, these displaced populations simply relocate to new informal settlements, exacerbating the slum problem.
  • Dual Urban Landscape: The stark contrast between gleaming high-rise buildings and sprawling informal settlements highlights the deep socio-economic inequalities within Indian cities. Slums often provide essential informal labor and services to the residents of the formal city, creating a symbiotic yet unequal relationship.

In summary: High land prices in large Indian cities act as a primary driver. To cope with these prices and accommodate population growth, cities resort to vertical development. However, this vertical growth primarily caters to higher-income groups, leaving the urban poor with no option but to create or expand informal settlements (slums) on whatever land is available and affordable, often in close proximity to the very areas experiencing vertical development. This creates a cycle where economic growth and modern urban development coexist with and, in some ways, contribute to the persistent challenge of slum proliferation.