Geography optional 2025 Paper II

With reference to international boundaries of India, discuss the related issues, giving suitable examples.

Verified Answer

India shares land boundaries with seven countries (Pakistan, Afghanistan, China, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Myanmar) and maritime boundaries with several others (Sri Lanka, Maldives, Indonesia, Thailand, Bangladesh, Pakistan). These diverse boundaries, spanning over 15,000 km of land and 7,500 km of coastline, give rise to a complex array of geopolitical, security, economic, and humanitarian issues.

Issues Related to India's International Boundaries:

  1. Territorial Disputes: These are perhaps the most significant and persistent issues, often leading to military standoffs and diplomatic tensions.

    • Example 1 (China): The Line of Actual Control (LAC) is largely undemarcated, leading to frequent incursions and standoffs, particularly in Aksai Chin (claimed by India, administered by China) and Arunachal Pradesh (claimed by China as South Tibet). The 1962 war and recent clashes like Galwan Valley (2020) highlight the volatility.
    • Example 2 (Pakistan): The dispute over Jammu & Kashmir, including the Line of Control (LoC), remains a flashpoint. Other disputes include Siachen Glacier (demarcated but militarized) and Sir Creek (a tidal estuary in the Rann of Kutch).
    • Example 3 (Nepal): Smaller but significant disputes exist over Kalapani, Lipulekh, and Susta, which have flared up periodically, impacting bilateral relations.
  2. Cross-border Terrorism and Insurgency: India faces significant security challenges from non-state actors operating across its borders.

    • Example 1 (Pakistan): State-sponsored terrorism emanating from Pakistan, particularly in Jammu & Kashmir, has been a major concern, with numerous attacks like the Mumbai attacks (2008) and Pulwama attack (2019).
    • Example 2 (Myanmar/Bangladesh): Insurgent groups from India's Northeast often seek refuge and operate from across the Myanmar and Bangladesh borders, posing challenges to internal security.
  3. Illegal Migration: Porous borders, especially with Bangladesh and Myanmar, lead to large-scale illegal migration, creating demographic shifts, resource strain, and social tensions.

    • Example (Bangladesh): Millions of undocumented immigrants from Bangladesh have settled in Indian states like West Bengal and Assam, leading to debates over citizenship and resource allocation.
    • Example (Myanmar): The recent political instability in Myanmar has led to an influx of Rohingya refugees and other migrants into India's northeastern states.
  4. Smuggling and Illicit Trade: Borders are often exploited for smuggling of drugs, arms, counterfeit currency, and human trafficking.

    • Example (Pakistan/Nepal): The 'Golden Crescent' (Afghanistan-Pakistan-Iran) route facilitates drug trafficking into India, often through the Punjab border. The open border with Nepal is also used for smuggling various goods and human trafficking.
    • Example (Myanmar): The 'Golden Triangle' (Myanmar-Laos-Thailand) is a source of illicit drugs entering India's Northeast.
  5. Resource Sharing Disputes: Sharing of transboundary rivers is a critical issue, particularly concerning water resources.

    • Example 1 (Bangladesh): The sharing of Ganga (Farakka Barrage) and Teesta river waters has been a long-standing issue, impacting agricultural livelihoods in both countries.
    • Example 2 (Pakistan): While the Indus Waters Treaty (1960) governs water sharing, disputes over specific projects on western rivers (e.g., Kishanganga, Ratle) occasionally arise.
  6. Maritime Boundary Issues: Delimitation of maritime boundaries and access to resources in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) can also lead to disputes.

    • Example 1 (Sri Lanka): The Katchatheevu island dispute and frequent arrests of Indian fishermen by Sri Lankan authorities for alleged poaching in their waters remain sensitive issues.
    • Example 2 (Bangladesh): While the maritime boundary in the Bay of Bengal was settled by international arbitration in 2014, ensuring sustainable resource management and preventing illegal fishing remains a challenge.
  7. Infrastructure Development and Connectivity: Developing border infrastructure (roads, railways, trade points) is crucial for economic integration and security, but often faces challenges due to difficult terrain, security concerns, and cross-border cooperation issues.

    • Example: Projects like the Kaladan Multi-Modal Transit Transport Project with Myanmar aim to enhance connectivity but face logistical and security hurdles.

Addressing these complex issues requires a multi-pronged approach involving robust border management, diplomatic engagement, regional cooperation, and sustainable development initiatives in border areas.