Law optional 2018 Paper I

Discuss the constitutionality of delegated legislation. What are the limits of delegated legislation? Explain.

Verified Answer
  1. Core Legal Answer & Context: Delegated legislation, also known as subordinate legislation, refers to laws made by an authority other than the legislature, under the power conferred by an Act of Parliament or a State Legislature. In India, the constitutionality of delegated legislation is a complex issue, as the Constitution does not explicitly provide for it. However, it is widely accepted as a practical necessity in modern governance due to several factors: the increasing volume and complexity of legislation, the need for flexibility and quick adaptation to changing circumstances, and the technical nature of many subjects requiring expert input. The judiciary has upheld its constitutionality, provided it adheres to certain well-defined limits.

The constitutional basis for delegated legislation is derived from the legislative powers of Parliament and State Legislatures (Articles 245 and 246). The principle is that the legislature, being the primary law-making body, can delegate its ancillary or subordinate functions to the executive or other bodies, but it cannot abdicate its 'essential legislative function'. The essential legislative function involves determining the legislative policy and enacting it into a binding rule of conduct. Once the policy is laid down, the legislature can delegate the power to fill in the details or make rules and regulations to implement that policy.

Limits of Delegated Legislation: The constitutionality of delegated legislation is maintained by imposing strict limits on the delegating authority and the delegate. These limits ensure that the delegated power is not exercised arbitrarily or in a manner that undermines the supremacy of the legislature or the Constitution. The limits can be broadly categorized as:

a. Constitutional Limits (Substantive Ultra Vires): * Essential Legislative Function: The legislature cannot delegate its essential legislative function, which includes determining the legislative policy. It must lay down the policy, principles, and standards, and only the power to fill in the details can be delegated. The delegate cannot make a law that goes beyond the policy laid down by the parent Act. * Violation of Fundamental Rights: Delegated legislation cannot violate any of the Fundamental Rights guaranteed by Part III of the Constitution. If a rule or regulation infringes upon a fundamental right, it can be struck down as unconstitutional. * Violation of Other Constitutional Provisions: Delegated legislation must conform to all other provisions of the Constitution, such as those relating to federalism, separation of powers, or judicial review. * Retrospective Operation: Generally, delegated legislation cannot be given retrospective effect unless the parent Act expressly or by necessary implication confers such power. * Exclusion of Judicial Review: The power to exclude judicial review cannot be delegated. Any attempt to make delegated legislation immune from judicial scrutiny would be unconstitutional.

b. Statutory Limits (Procedural Ultra Vires): * Ultra Vires the Parent Act: The delegated legislation must be within the scope and ambit of the power conferred by the enabling (parent) Act. If it goes beyond the powers granted by the parent Act, it is considered 'ultra vires' and void. * Procedural Requirements: The parent Act often prescribes certain procedures for making delegated legislation (e.g., prior publication, consultation with affected parties, laying before Parliament/State Legislature). Failure to follow these mandatory procedures renders the delegated legislation invalid. * Sub-delegation: The delegate cannot further delegate its delegated power unless the parent Act expressly or impliedly permits such sub-delegation (the maxim delegatus non potest delegare – a delegate cannot further delegate).

c. General Principles of Law (Ancillary Limits): * Reasonableness: Delegated legislation must be reasonable and not arbitrary or capricious. It should not impose unreasonable restrictions or burdens. * Natural Justice: Where the delegated power affects rights or interests, principles of natural justice (e.g., right to be heard) must be observed, unless specifically excluded by the parent Act.

  1. Relevant Statutes and Sections:
  • Articles 245 and 246: These articles define the legislative powers of Parliament and State Legislatures, from which the power to delegate is derived.
  • General Clauses Act, 1897: Contains provisions relating to the construction of statutes, including rules and regulations made under them.
  • Various Enabling Acts: Specific Acts of Parliament or State Legislatures that confer power to make rules, regulations, bye-laws, etc.
  1. Important Landmark Cases:
  • In Re Delhi Laws Act, 1912 (1951): This was the first major case where the Supreme Court extensively discussed the constitutionality of delegated legislation. While upholding the principle of permissible delegation, the Court laid down the doctrine of 'essential legislative function', stating that the legislature cannot delegate its essential function of laying down policy.
  • Hamdard Dawakhana v. Union of India (1960): The Supreme Court reiterated that the essential legislative function, which involves determining the legislative policy, cannot be delegated. The delegate can only be entrusted with the power to carry out the policy within the framework of the parent Act.
  • K.T. Plantation Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (2011): The Supreme Court emphasized that delegated legislation must be within the four corners of the parent statute and the Constitution. It cannot be used to bring about a fundamental change in the law or to impose a tax unless specifically authorized by the parent Act.
  1. Clear Conclusion: Delegated legislation is a constitutional necessity in modern administrative states, allowing for efficient and flexible governance. Its constitutionality in India is well-established, provided it operates within strict limits. The primary limit is that the legislature must retain its 'essential legislative function' of policy-making, delegating only the power to fill in details or implement that policy. Furthermore, delegated legislation must not violate any constitutional provisions, particularly Fundamental Rights, and must strictly adhere to the powers and procedures laid down in the parent Act. Judicial review serves as a crucial check to ensure that delegated legislation remains within these constitutional and statutory bounds, preventing the executive from overstepping its authority and safeguarding the rule of law.