Political Science and IR Optional 2021 Paper II
  1. (b) How do the constituent states influence the foreign policy making process in India?
Verified Answer

While foreign policy is primarily the domain of the central government in India, the constituent states, particularly those bordering other countries or having significant diaspora populations, exert considerable influence on the foreign policy-making process. This influence manifests in several ways:

  1. Border States and Bilateral Relations: States sharing borders with neighboring countries often have a direct stake in bilateral relations. For instance:

    • West Bengal and Bangladesh: Issues like the Teesta River water-sharing agreement are heavily influenced by the West Bengal government's stance, as water is a critical resource for its agriculture. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's opposition has stalled the agreement for years.
    • Punjab and Pakistan: Cross-border trade, cultural exchanges, and issues related to Sikh pilgrims visiting shrines in Pakistan are important for Punjab. Any deterioration in India-Pakistan relations directly impacts the state.
    • Northeastern States and Myanmar/Bangladesh: States like Mizoram, Manipur, and Assam are directly affected by cross-border insurgencies, drug trafficking, and refugee influxes (e.g., Rohingya from Bangladesh, Chins from Myanmar). Their concerns often shape India's border management and refugee policies.
  2. Diaspora and Ethnic Linkages: States with significant ethnic or linguistic ties to communities in neighboring countries can influence policy. For example:

    • Tamil Nadu and Sri Lanka: The plight of Sri Lankan Tamils and issues concerning Indian fishermen in the Palk Strait are highly emotive in Tamil Nadu. State political parties often pressure the central government to adopt a particular stance towards Sri Lanka.
    • Kerala and Gulf Countries: Kerala's large diaspora in the Middle East means that issues related to migrant workers' welfare, remittances, and diplomatic relations with Gulf nations are of paramount importance to the state government and its electorate.
  3. Economic Interests and Trade: State governments often advocate for policies that promote their economic interests, such as cross-border trade, investment, or tourism. For example, states might push for better connectivity projects or trade agreements that benefit their local industries.

  4. Federal Structure and Consultative Mechanisms: Although foreign policy is a Union subject, the central government often consults state governments on issues that directly impact them. This can happen through inter-state councils, chief ministers' conferences, or direct communication, especially when negotiating treaties or agreements that have implications for state resources or populations.

  5. Political Pressure and Electoral Considerations: State-level political parties and leaders can exert pressure on the central government, particularly if they are part of a ruling coalition or if their electoral prospects are tied to specific foreign policy outcomes. Public opinion within states can also shape the national discourse on foreign policy issues.

In conclusion, while the Union government holds the constitutional mandate for foreign policy, the diverse interests, geographical realities, and political dynamics of India's constituent states ensure that they are not mere spectators but active, albeit indirect, participants in shaping the nation's external relations.