- (c) विधान परिषद् बिना प्रभावशाली शक्तियों वाला सदन है। टिप्पणी कीजिए। Legislative Council is a house without any effective powers. Comment.
The Legislative Council (Vidhan Parishad) in Indian states is often considered a house without effective powers, especially when compared to the Legislative Assembly (Vidhan Sabha). Its powers are significantly limited, making it a subordinate body. Regarding ordinary bills, the Council can only delay a bill passed by the Assembly for a maximum of four months (three months initially, and one month upon reconsideration). If the Assembly passes the bill again, the Council cannot stop it.
In the case of money bills, the Council's powers are even more restricted. It can only delay a money bill for 14 days and cannot amend or reject it. The Assembly is not bound by the Council's recommendations. Furthermore, the Council has no say in the election of the Chief Minister or the formation of the government, as the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible only to the Legislative Assembly. While it serves as a deliberative body, provides a platform for diverse representation (e.g., teachers, graduates, local bodies), and can scrutinize legislation, its lack of substantial legislative, financial, and executive powers renders it largely ineffective in shaping policy or challenging the will of the elected Assembly. Its existence is often debated due to its limited utility and the financial burden it imposes.