Political Science and IR Optional 2022 Paper I

Examine the unique features of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment. Do you think this Amendment would contribute in achieving the goal of empowerment of marginalised sections of the society?

Verified Answer

The 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act of 1992 marked a watershed moment in India's democratic journey by granting constitutional status to Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs). It aimed to decentralize power and deepen democracy at the grassroots level. Its unique features are designed to ensure the effective functioning and democratic character of these local self-governing bodies.

Unique Features of the 73rd Constitutional Amendment:

  1. Constitutional Status: It made the establishment of Panchayats mandatory, moving them from Directive Principles to enforceable constitutional provisions.
  2. Three-Tier System: Mandated a uniform three-tier structure of Panchayats at the village, intermediate (block), and district levels across states with a population exceeding 20 lakhs.
  3. Gram Sabha: Made the Gram Sabha (village assembly) the foundation of the Panchayati Raj system, empowering it to perform functions and exercise powers as determined by the state legislature. It is envisioned as a direct democracy forum.
  4. Regular Elections: Ensured regular and timely elections (every five years) to Panchayats. If a Panchayat is dissolved prematurely, fresh elections must be held within six months.
  5. Reservation of Seats: Provided for mandatory reservation of seats for Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) in proportion to their population at all three levels. Crucially, it mandated reservation of not less than one-third of the total seats for women, including those reserved for SCs and STs.
  6. Reservation of Chairpersons: Extended the reservation principle to the offices of chairpersons at all three levels for SCs, STs, and women.
  7. State Election Commission (SEC): Established an independent State Election Commission in each state to conduct, superintend, direct, and control the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of all Panchayat elections.
  8. State Finance Commission (SFC): Mandated the constitution of a State Finance Commission every five years to review the financial position of Panchayats and recommend measures for financial devolution from the state government.
  9. Devolution of Powers and Responsibilities: Enlisted 29 subjects in the Eleventh Schedule of the Constitution, over which Panchayats are to be endowed with powers and responsibilities for economic development and social justice.

Contribution to Empowerment of Marginalised Sections: Yes, the 73rd Amendment has significantly contributed to the empowerment of marginalised sections, though its full potential is still being realized.

  • Political Empowerment: The most direct impact is political empowerment. Mandatory reservations for SCs, STs, and women have ensured their representation in local governance bodies. This has brought individuals from these historically disadvantaged groups into decision-making roles, giving them a voice and a platform they previously lacked. Women, in particular, have emerged as powerful agents of change in many villages, challenging patriarchal norms.
  • Increased Participation: The presence of reserved seats has encouraged greater political participation from these sections, leading to increased awareness of their rights and responsibilities.
  • Addressing Local Needs: Representatives from marginalised communities are often more attuned to the specific needs and grievances of their constituents, leading to more targeted development initiatives and social justice programs at the local level.
  • Breaking Traditional Hierarchies: The amendment has, to some extent, challenged traditional power structures and social hierarchies by legally mandating the inclusion of previously excluded groups in positions of authority.

Challenges and Limitations: Despite these positive contributions, challenges remain:

  • Proxy Representation: The phenomenon of 'Sarpanch Pati' (where male relatives effectively run the Panchayat on behalf of elected women) or 'proxy' candidates for SC/STs still exists in some areas.
  • Lack of Genuine Devolution: Many state governments have been reluctant to fully devolve financial and administrative powers to Panchayats, limiting their autonomy and effectiveness.
  • Continued Dominance of Elites: Traditional elites and dominant castes can still exert influence, sometimes undermining the agency of elected representatives from marginalised groups.
  • Capacity Building: Lack of education, training, and resources for elected representatives from marginalised sections can hinder their ability to perform effectively.

In conclusion, the 73rd Constitutional Amendment is a revolutionary step towards empowering marginalised sections by constitutionally guaranteeing their political representation and participation in local governance. While implementation challenges persist, it has undeniably laid a strong foundation for a more inclusive and equitable democratic system, fostering a quiet social revolution at the grassroots.