Political Science and IR Optional 2025 Paper II

Explain the non-traditional security threats in the context of food and environmental crises.

Verified Answer

Non-traditional security (NTS) threats represent a broadening of the security agenda beyond the traditional focus on military threats to state sovereignty and territorial integrity. NTS threats are typically non-military in nature, often transnational, and directly impact human well-being, state stability, and global peace. Food and environmental crises are prime examples of such threats, posing complex and interconnected challenges.

Food Crises as Non-Traditional Security Threats: Food security refers to the condition where all people, at all times, have physical, social, and economic access to sufficient, safe, and nutritious food that meets their dietary needs and food preferences for an active and healthy life. Food crises, characterized by widespread food insecurity, become NTS threats because they can:

  1. Trigger Social Unrest and Political Instability: Food price spikes, scarcity, or famine can lead to protests, riots, and even regime change, as seen in the Arab Spring uprisings where rising food prices were a significant factor.
  2. Exacerbate Conflicts: Competition over scarce food resources, particularly in regions already prone to conflict, can intensify existing tensions or ignite new ones.
  3. Drive Mass Migration: People facing starvation or chronic food insecurity are often forced to migrate, creating humanitarian crises and potentially straining resources and social cohesion in host communities.
  4. Undermine State Capacity: Governments struggling to feed their populations lose legitimacy and capacity to govern, potentially leading to state fragility or collapse.
  5. Impact Human Development: Chronic malnutrition and food insecurity have long-term effects on health, education, and economic productivity, hindering national development.

Environmental Crises as Non-Traditional Security Threats: Environmental degradation and climate change represent a profound and existential NTS threat. These crises include:

  1. Climate Change: Rising sea levels threaten coastal communities and small island states, leading to displacement and loss of territory. Extreme weather events (droughts, floods, heatwaves) destroy infrastructure, disrupt agriculture, and cause humanitarian disasters. Climate change can also lead to resource scarcity, fueling conflicts over water and arable land.
  2. Resource Depletion: Over-exploitation of vital resources like fresh water, fertile land, and fish stocks can lead to scarcity, economic collapse for dependent communities, and cross-border disputes.
  3. Pollution: Air, water, and soil pollution have severe public health consequences, leading to diseases and reduced life expectancy, which can strain healthcare systems and national productivity.
  4. Biodiversity Loss: The degradation of ecosystems reduces their capacity to provide essential services (e.g., clean water, pollination), impacting food security and human well-being.

Interconnectedness: Food and environmental crises are deeply intertwined. Climate change, for instance, directly impacts agricultural yields, exacerbating food insecurity. Deforestation contributes to climate change and soil erosion, further reducing food production capacity. These crises often disproportionately affect vulnerable populations and developing countries, creating a vicious cycle of poverty, instability, and environmental degradation. Addressing these NTS threats requires comprehensive, multilateral approaches that integrate development, environmental protection, and peacebuilding strategies.