Political Science and IR Optional 2025 Paper II

India continues to invoke its time-tested policy of strategic autonomy vis-à-vis both the United States of America and Russia by rejecting US' offer of mediation on Kashmir issue and by refusing to criticize Russia in its ongoing war against Ukraine. Comment.

Verified Answer

India's foreign policy is fundamentally guided by the principle of strategic autonomy, a time-tested approach that prioritizes national interests and independent decision-making over alignment with any particular power bloc. This policy is evident in its nuanced engagement with both the United States and Russia, particularly concerning the Kashmir issue and the Ukraine conflict.

Regarding the United States' offer of mediation on Kashmir, India has consistently rejected any third-party intervention. This stance is rooted in its long-held position that Kashmir is a bilateral issue with Pakistan, as enshrined in the Simla Agreement of 1972. Accepting US mediation would not only undermine India's sovereignty over the region but also set a precedent for external interference in its internal affairs. India views such offers as an attempt to internationalize a matter it considers strictly bilateral, and its refusal is a clear assertion of its sovereign right to manage its own territorial disputes without external pressure.

Similarly, India's refusal to openly criticize Russia for its actions in Ukraine is a direct manifestation of its strategic autonomy. This position is shaped by several factors:

  1. Historical Ties and Defense Dependence: Russia has been a long-standing and reliable defense partner for India, supplying a significant portion of its military hardware. A strong relationship with Russia is crucial for India's defense preparedness, especially given its complex security environment.
  2. Energy Security: India relies on Russian oil and other commodities, which have become more accessible and affordable amidst Western sanctions. Diversifying its energy sources and securing affordable supplies is a key national interest.
  3. Multipolar Worldview: India advocates for a multipolar world order and believes in resolving conflicts through dialogue and diplomacy rather than through sanctions and military confrontation. Its non-condemnatory stance aligns with its broader foreign policy of not taking sides in great power rivalries.
  4. Balancing Act: India maintains robust strategic partnerships with the US and its allies, particularly in the Indo-Pacific, to counter China's growing influence. However, it simultaneously seeks to preserve its relationship with Russia to avoid becoming overly dependent on any single power and to maintain leverage in its foreign policy.

In essence, India's actions are a pragmatic response to its complex geopolitical environment. By rejecting mediation on Kashmir and refraining from criticizing Russia, India demonstrates its commitment to an independent foreign policy that prioritizes its national security, economic development, and strategic interests. This approach allows India to maximize its options, engage with multiple partners, and assert its growing role as an independent global power, rather than being a junior partner in any alliance.