Sociology Optional 2017 Paper II

What is the nature of religious change among tribal communities? Illustrate with two examples from colonial and post independence times.

Verified Answer

Religious change among tribal communities in India is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon, driven by internal dynamics and external pressures from dominant religions, colonial powers, and the modern state. It often involves processes of conversion, syncretism, revitalization, and politicization.

Nature of Religious Change:

  1. Conversion: Many tribal communities have converted to major religions, primarily Christianity and Hinduism. This is often influenced by factors such as access to education, healthcare, protection from exploitation, or the promise of social mobility.
  2. Syncretism: Rather than a complete abandonment of traditional beliefs, many tribes exhibit syncretism, blending elements of their indigenous animistic or nature-worshipping religions with practices and deities from Hinduism or Christianity. This creates unique hybrid religious forms.
  3. Revitalization Movements: In response to external pressures and the perceived threat to their distinct identity, some tribal communities have initiated revitalization movements. These movements aim to revive, purify, and codify their traditional religions, often seeking official recognition and asserting their unique cultural heritage.
  4. Sanskritization/Hinduization: Some tribes have adopted Hindu rituals, deities, and social practices, a process often termed Sanskritization or Hinduization. This can be a conscious effort to gain higher social status or a result of sustained interaction and integration with Hindu society.
  5. Politicization of Religion: Religious identity among tribes has increasingly become a tool for political mobilization, assertion of rights, and demands for autonomy or special status within the Indian state.

Illustrative Examples:

1. Colonial Period: Conversion to Christianity among Munda and Oraon Tribes (Chota Nagpur Region, Jharkhand)

  • Context: During the British colonial period, tribal communities in the Chota Nagpur plateau (present-day Jharkhand) faced severe exploitation. They suffered from land alienation by non-tribal landlords (zamindars), oppressive forest laws, and economic subjugation by moneylenders. Their traditional social and political systems were disrupted.
  • Nature of Change: Christian missionaries (e.g., German Lutherans, Roman Catholics) arrived in the region in the mid-19th century. They offered education, healthcare, and legal assistance to the tribals, often acting as intermediaries against the exploitative colonial administration and landlords. For many Munda and Oraon tribals, conversion to Christianity provided a new sense of community, identity, and a means to resist oppression. It offered a pathway to social upliftment and protection, leading to mass conversions in some areas.
  • Impact: While providing significant benefits in terms of education and social justice, conversion also led to internal divisions within tribal communities (Christian vs. non-Christian tribals). It introduced new cultural practices and sometimes alienated converts from their traditional customs, though many retained elements of their indigenous beliefs in a syncretic manner.

2. Post-Independence Period: The Sarna Dharma Movement (Jharkhand and neighboring states)

  • Context: In the post-independence era, tribal communities, particularly in Jharkhand, continued to face pressures from both Hinduization and Christian conversion. There was a growing realization among many tribals that their distinct indigenous religious identity was being subsumed under either Hinduism or Christianity, leading to a loss of cultural uniqueness and land rights.
  • Nature of Change: The Sarna Dharma movement emerged as a powerful revitalization and assertion of indigenous tribal religion. 'Sarna' refers to the sacred grove, which is central to tribal worship of nature spirits (Bonga). The movement seeks official recognition for Sarna as a separate religious code in the Indian census, distinct from Hinduism, Christianity, or other major religions. It emphasizes the worship of nature, ancestral spirits, and traditional rituals, rejecting the caste hierarchy of Hinduism and the proselytizing nature of Christianity.
  • Impact: The Sarna Dharma movement is a strong assertion of tribal identity and a demand for cultural and religious autonomy. It aims to protect tribal land, language, and customs, and to unite various tribal groups under a common indigenous religious banner. It has become a significant political and cultural force, highlighting the ongoing struggle of tribal communities to maintain their distinct identity in a diverse and rapidly changing India.