Sociology Optional 2020 Paper I

Q3. (b) Critically analyse Durkheim's views on elementary forms of religious life and role of religion. Also discuss the consequences of religious revivalism in contemporary society.

Verified Answer

Émile Durkheim, a foundational figure in sociology, profoundly analyzed religion in his seminal work, The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. He argued that religion is fundamentally a social phenomenon, originating from society itself, rather than from divine revelation or individual psychology.

Durkheim's Views on Religion:

  1. Sacred and Profane: Durkheim posited that all societies divide the world into two distinct categories: the sacred and the profane. The sacred encompasses things set apart, forbidden, and inspiring awe (e.g., gods, rituals, totems), while the profane refers to the ordinary, mundane aspects of daily life. This distinction is crucial for social order.
  2. Collective Effervescence: He observed that during religious rituals and gatherings, individuals experience intense emotional states, a sense of shared excitement and energy, which he termed 'collective effervescence.' In these moments, individuals feel connected to something larger than themselves. Durkheim argued that this 'something' is society itself, deified and worshipped.
  3. Totemism as Elementary Form: Studying Australian Aboriginal totemism, Durkheim concluded it was the most elementary form of religion. The totem, a sacred object or animal, represented both the clan and the sacred. By worshipping the totem, the clan was, in essence, worshipping itself – its collective identity and moral authority.
  4. Functions of Religion: For Durkheim, religion serves vital social functions:
    • Social Cohesion: It binds individuals together through shared beliefs, rituals, and a common moral framework, fostering a sense of community and solidarity.
    • Moral Regulation: Religion provides a moral code, reinforcing social norms and values, thereby maintaining social order and discipline.
    • Sense of Purpose and Meaning: It offers explanations for life's mysteries, suffering, and death, providing individuals with a sense of meaning and purpose.
    • Social Control: It enforces conformity to societal expectations through its moral authority and sanctions.

Critique of Durkheim's Views: While insightful, Durkheim's perspective has been critiqued for:

  • Overemphasis on Social Function: It may overlook the individual spiritual experience, the role of religion in generating conflict, or its potential for social change rather than just stability.
  • Applicability to Complex Societies: Using totemism as a universal model might be too simplistic for understanding the diverse and often fragmented religious landscapes of modern, complex societies.
  • Ignoring Power Dynamics: He did not fully address how religion can be used by powerful groups to maintain their dominance or how religious institutions can become sources of inequality.

Consequences of Religious Revivalism in Contemporary Society: Religious revivalism refers to a renewed interest in and commitment to religious beliefs and practices, often accompanied by a desire to restore traditional values. Its consequences are multifaceted:

Positive Consequences:

  • Community Building: Revivalist movements can strengthen social bonds, provide a strong sense of identity, belonging, and mutual support for adherents.
  • Moral Renewal and Social Activism: They can inspire ethical behavior, promote social service, and mobilize people for social justice causes or charitable work.
  • Cultural Preservation: Revivalism can help preserve traditional cultural practices, languages, and art forms associated with a particular religion.

Negative Consequences:

  • Exclusion and Intolerance: Revivalist movements often emphasize a strict interpretation of doctrine, leading to fundamentalism, sectarianism, and intolerance towards other religious groups or secular viewpoints. This can fuel social division and conflict.
  • Political Polarization and Extremism: Religion can be instrumentalized for political mobilization, leading to the rise of religious nationalism, political polarization, and, in extreme cases, violence and terrorism.
  • Suppression of Dissent and Individual Freedoms: Strict adherence to traditional religious norms can lead to the suppression of individual freedoms, critical thinking, and dissent, particularly concerning gender roles, sexuality, and scientific inquiry.
  • Obstruction of Social Progress: Some revivalist movements may resist scientific advancements, modern education, or social reforms that challenge their traditional worldview, potentially hindering societal development.

In conclusion, Durkheim's analysis highlights religion's crucial role in social integration and moral regulation. However, contemporary religious revivalism demonstrates that while religion can foster community and moral purpose, it also carries the potential for significant social division, intolerance, and conflict in a diverse and globalized world.